Tamil Nadu Elections: Kalaignar 's Swan Song?

Neither age nor the Tamil Nadu voter is ready to show any kindness to the old warhorse whose seven-decade long political career is in its late stages

Published: Apr 4, 2011
Tamil Nadu Elections: Kalaignar 's Swan Song?
Image: Babu Babu/Reuters

Those who stray from the moral path will have neither peace in success not fortitude in tribulation; their pain is like that of the palanquin-carrier who cannot put his burden away  
–M. Karunanidhi in Kuraloviyam, a commentary on Thirukkural 

Those with even a passing knowledge of Tamil Nadu politics know that it is an accepted practice there to bribe voters with hard cash to persuade them to vote in a particular way. Things came to such a pass in recent bye-elections that some voters even auctioned their suffrage to the highest bidder. The current inflation-adjusted rate is about Rs. 6,000 per smudged finger in a Legislative Assembly election.

So it is reasonable to surmise that as election fever grips the state, political workers crisscrossing the 234 constituencies should be carrying stashes of cash. Indeed, the election commission and the income tax department thought so too; their flying squads checked passing cars and raided the houses of political workers. And what a rich haul they made! Within a week, they seized Rs.20 crore in unaccounted money. Naturally, no party claimed ownership or asked for the cash back.

That’s a pittance in the state that gave the nation its largest ever corruption scandal, worth Rs. 176,000 crore.

The cash-for-vote culture is just a footnote in the orgy of scandals that the ruling party Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) has spearheaded in the last few years. Neither the party nor its leader, Muthuvel Karunanidhi, is a stranger to corruption charges. As early as 35 years ago, a panel called Sarkaria Commission described DMK as the masters of ‘scientific corruption’, the variety that leaves no trace.

That description is being recalled now as DMK fights to return to power in the state in the wake of the 2G Spectrum scam and widespread charges that Karunanidhi’s family and relatives control virtually everything from the grant of government contracts to real estate deals to private business. “The first and foremost issue among voters today is not just the corruption but how the civil society has been betrayed and one family has gathered such clout and power,” says Professor Ramu Manivannan, who teaches political science at the University of Madras.

There is no doubt that a strong anti-incumbency wave is sweeping over Tamil Nadu. The DMK was the first to admit this, albeit tacitly. Karunanidhi kept quiet when the Centre began investigating the 2G scam and got the tainted ex-telecom minister, A. Raja, arrested. At a party meeting, when angry leaders spoke in favour of snapping ties with the Congress, Karunanidhi silenced them. He said no such possibility should even be considered. He also succumbed to Congress pressure in the seat-sharing talks, giving his ally both the number and choice of seats.

A Time for Change
A Forbes India correspondent who travelled across Tamil Nadu reports that the anger against corruption is more pronounced in urban areas while soaring prices of food and essential commodities are the prime concern in villages. Tamilarasi, 25, a mother of two and a farm worker in Alagarkovil near Madurai, says everything from food prices to bus fare has gone up in the last three or four years. “I spend much more to feed my younger son than I spent on my elder one when he was that age,” she says. Her family can no longer afford the usual excursions to Madurai city. Devadoss, a cab driver in Chennai, feels the same pinch too: “Amma (AIADMK supremo Jayalalithaa) would have done something. Kalaignar (Karunanidhi) doesn’t care.”

But then, an anti-incumbency mood is the default state of mind among Tamil Nadu voters. The last time they returned a ruling party to power was 27 years ago. They also don’t vote in half measures. From Chennai to Kanyakumari, from Ooty to Nagapattinam, they speak in one voice. This makes the Opposition party’s task very simple: Just keep quiet and win. In fact, that’s what AIADMK plans to do, senior party leader C. Ponnaian, says. “We don’t even need any specific strategy for this election. The public has already made up its mind to vote against Karunanidhi for his anti-people activities. We just have to harvest the wave.”

Karunanidhi has spared no expense — be it the party’s money or the government’s — to reduce the intensity of this wave. Tamil Nadu has a well-entrenched culture of freebies. From sarees to wedding jewelry to plots of land to colour television sets, the government just keeps giving and the people just keep taking. Karunanidhi took the practice one notch higher by distributing colour TVs to even affluent families. Never mind that his second wife and daughter run a TV channel and his grand-nephews own South India’s largest broadcast network.

Tamil Nadu Elections: Kalaignar 's Swan Song?
Image: STR New/Reuters

Karunanidhi has faced such desperation only on two occasions since he first became chief minister 42 years ago. In 1984, he got posters pasted across the state, showing him in a friendly chat with the then chief minister, M.G. Ramachandran (MGR), whom he was hoping to defeat at the hustings. The idea was that public would be less hostile to him if their star-hero MGR were shown to be a friend of his.

The next time was in 1991 after the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi. People blamed the DMK regime in 1989-1991 for allowing the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam to build up its network in the state and run guns. In the ensuing elections, his party was routed.

A New Era in State Politics
The 2011 Assembly elections are a major turning point in the political history of Tamil Nadu for at least four reasons.

Tamil Nadu is best known as the hotbed of the Dravidian movement, the non-Hindi, anti-Congress movement in Tamil Nadu that started in 1925 fighting issues like untouchability. The DMK, a part of that movement, took to the political platform to achieve its aims. But in time, it got sucked up in the web of cutthroat politics, dropping its agenda one by one. Also, the early leaders of the movement are long gone, leaving behind a lone General in the form of ‘Kalaignar’ Karunanidhi.


‘Kalaignar’, a prolific writer and a fighter with enormous staying power, is getting old. He is 86 and wheelchair-bound. It is an open secret that the government is run by his son, M.K. Stalin (born the same week as Russian leader Joseph Stalin died). Karunanidhi may not be able to ignore old age much longer. In the next elections in 2016, he would be 91, and too old for the bloody games of politics he once reveled in.

So, the current elections may well be the last for the classical Dravidian movement. A number of parties have prefixed ‘Dravida’ to their name but there is no one in those parties who can claim that legacy. Cinema is the only political ideology now in the state, ruled by film icons for the past 42 years.

The polls will also mark a generational change in Tamil Nadu politics after 22 years. It was in 1989 that Jayalalithaa led a faction of the AIADMK for the first time into the polls. Karunanidhi, who had fought against the likes of Kamaraj, Rajaji and MGR, is still reeling under the impact of her charisma.

Today, his own sons — Stalin and M.K. Azhagiri — are ready to replace him. The Congress party is increasingly leaning towards new leaders like G.K. Vasan and Karthi Chidambaram. Actor Vijaykanth has become a force to reckon with. These are the people that Jayalalithaa will henceforth worry about, not the old warhorse.

With so many leaders, votes are getting fragmented. The state’s vote bank first moved beyond the three giants—DMK, AIADMK and the Congress—in 1991 when PMK fought on a casteist agenda. More parties cropped up after that. All of them had to align with either DMK or AIADMK to survive, but that also meant the two giants had to part with more constituencies.

This time, the DMK is contesting in only 121 seats, just three more than the half-way mark. The AIADMK, too, has a number of smaller parties in its alliance and has been locked in a battle of nerves with them over seat-sharing. In other words, the two major parties will have to consider alliance partners in power equations. This could well be the dawn of coalition era in the state.

The fourth factor that makes this Assembly election so interesting to watch is the shrewd way in which the Congress Party is trying to reinvent itself in Tamil Nadu. It is fully exploiting the misfortune of DMK, forcing it to give away 63 seats, 15 more than the 2006 elections, and has cornered some juicy constituencies. Over the years, the vote share of Congress has fallen from 20 percent to just 8 percent. This  is its best chance to reverse the trend.

Should the alliance scrape through, the Congress will dictate to DMK on government formation. But for now, the biggest worry for both parties is to get their hostile cadres to work together and put up a bloody good fight.

(This story appears in the 08 April, 2011 issue of Forbes India. You can buy our tablet version from Magzter.com. To visit our Archives, click here.)

Show More
Post Your Comment
Required, will not be published
All comments are moderated
  • Vaidya

    DMK GOVERNMENT OR DR Kalaignar"s corruptions touched the sky and created the record in the History of world and yet the concerned authorities is just waiting for the election to be over, but DAMAGE HAS BEEN DONE AND NOT RECOVERABLE.

    on Apr 6, 2011
  • Seyoan

    An Apt title for this article would be 'In the dream if an ADMK zealot'.

    on Apr 6, 2011
  • Swaminathan

    Corruption was in existance even during AIADMK Rule. Remember TANSI land Acquisition By Jaya and Acid incidence on ex-collector...

    on Apr 4, 2011
  • Hope Sails

    Sridhar Goswami is absolutely right. I'm flummoxed that an article of such bad standards is featured in Forbes. Anti-incumbency factor has always been there; but that in no way makes Jayalalithaa any better. In fact, there was absolutely no development during her rule. All that she successfully did was repressing workers with TESMA and ESMA laws, and suppressing minorities with that dumb 'Anti-conversion' law.

    on Apr 4, 2011
  • Sridhar Goswami

    I'm just wondering what is this article all about? Is this a Forbes Indian assessment or so- called election results assessment? Since when did Forbes start writing some half baked, "masala peppered" TOI kinda articles? The article neither sings the full song of swan or both, Srinivasan & Ramnath couldnt articulate their compressed angers well enough against the "wearing off Dravidian pontiff" in Tamilnadu. As a note in point, not just the ageing gentleman, but Jayalalitha Iyengar herself has swindled, corrupted and got kicked out off her last term..What amuses me is the percolation of "caste" tempo that still keeps the likes of srinivasans and ramnath's to come out with such half baked, direction floundering articles..good enough to find fault with the ageing old dravidian leader who literally crucified the prospects of forward cast in tamilnadu!!!!cheers Goswami!..

    on Apr 4, 2011
    • Vetrichelvan

      Dear Mr.Go swamy, r u still in 1950 s.How many upper castes are there in Amma s ministry or candidate.In fact it was amma who introduced 67% reservation which this old man was only talking off.What development this old man did.R u talking of development of Alagiri,Kanimoli,Rajathi,Dayalu.Can u name single develoment this old man did.Other than Re 1 rice from tax payers money.Today all DMK ministers are owning palatial colleges,bunglows.TN s biggest college is coming up near Madurai named as Daya engg college by Alagiri .. Your note is absolutely nonsense.It is well known to even a villager the Kalainer TV was started from 2G scam money.

      on Apr 4, 2011
      • Sridhar.goswami

        Vetri -Did u mean JJ? For a second, I was wondering whom AMMA meant!!!. JJ is suppsoedly single hence the quantum of money swindled cannot equate the DMK...Corruption as a measure - both are in the same boat. In terms of plausible policies, DMK is far better in terms of impact. Between the two devils, DMK is by far better. 2G story is much beyond what you and I know.. Next time, just call your mother alone AMMA.. Dont lend Amma nickname to anyone else.. samjhe?

        on Apr 5, 2011
  • Kumar

    TN is one of the most educated, developed, peaceful states in India. TN is the only state where women are empowered the most. All parties give cash for votes, but I dont think people of TN are influenced by such allurements. Even after receiving the gift, people will vote for whom ever they wish. We need programs to remove the imparity in the society at the same time without making the people lazy. Historically, TN has developed more during DMK period. Nepotism and favouritism are part of governence in India, no exception.

    on Apr 4, 2011
  • L.somasundaram

    Very good analysis!Worth reading.

    on Apr 4, 2011
When the Milk Runs Dry: India's New Dairy Policy
The Accelerator - M.M. Singh from Maruti Suzuki