At the Jamshed Bhabha Theatre at the National Centre for the Performing Arts (NCPA), Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony is holding Mumbai’s posh set in thrall. As the Symphony Orchestra of India (SOI) weaves its way through the second movement and ends it with a flourish, a section of the audience breaks into applause.
If you are a Western classical music purist, you must be frowning; after all, concert etiquette demands that you never clap between movements. Your thoughts would be in line with what British classical music and opera journalist Jonathan Lennie wrote in his open letter to the “loud clapping man who sits behind me at concerts”: “Having sat through a long and profound work, why do you have to start making a racket as soon as you perceive it to be over?”
But Khushroo N Suntook, the NCPA chairman, refuses to turn his nose up at such transgressions: “It’s good in a way that we are moving away from the coughless audience. It indicates that a new generation is coming in. To survive, Western classical music needs this audience first. Etiquette can come later. We can always announce when not to clap.”
Upbeat
Closed Encounters
Overtures
(This story appears in the 03 October, 2014 issue of Forbes India. To visit our Archives, click here.)
India has it\'s own classical music , no need to impose western crap on us please
on Oct 4, 2014Interesting article, as a member of SOI i\'m committed to furthering the cause of the SOI and Western Classical Music in India. I believe all persons have a right to it and hope that all sections of Indian society will be able to experience Western Classical Music and will want to take up the learning of orchestral instruments so that SOI will truly become the Orchestra for India. Sadly much work is needed in this area as, like your article suggests, that no one musical institution has worked together to produce Indian musicians of international calibre. My hope is that the SOI and others can work together to begin this process. It will take a long time but the results will be wonderful for the cultural scene in India.
on Oct 3, 2014Thanks Forbes for this article. Really enjoyed reading. I trained in piano as a child and wanted to study music but could not pursue it further because of familial pressures.There was no future in such music people said. Nice to know that Indians are accepting western classical even if that is a small number and only in some cities.
on Sep 29, 2014