Indians Can't Work, Chinese Can't Think

When Prakash Menon stepped off the boat 12 years ago to set up NIIT's operations in China, he was wet behind the ears. But then, men learn and live to tell their tale

Published: May 18, 2009

Back in 1997 when I landed here, China was a different country.
It was still opening up. Expats were very few and China wasn’t yet making the headlines. Private education was a big no-no. NIIT had to take permissions from six bureaus and was allowed to do business only in Shanghai.
Today, NIIT is working with 135 universities in China. NIIT’s course is now part of the college curriculum. China, the world factory, too, has come a long way with its sizzling growth.
What strikes you most about China is that once the goal is set, the entire state machinery works towards it. Last year, 1.4 million Chinese graduates could not find a job. Last year, the mayor of Wuxi city came and said, “Tell us what you need — we want you to train our kids.” They did everything — set up a physical infrastructure to train 1,000 and a dorm for 600 students besides offering 3,000 Renminbi as course subsidy — 30 percent of our annual fee. Now, the mayors of Chong Qing, Dalian and Chengdu have asked us to replicate the model in their cities. As long as our course helps the Chinese youth get jobs, they are willing to support us.

An Unromantic Country
The Chinese Wall defines their state of mind. They are building the $30-billion Three-Gorges Dam, the largest hydro-electric power station. It’s not that Chinese labour is cheap — it’s the indirect subsidy in the form of outstanding infrastructure that makes it work for companies here.
China’s impressive infrastructure awes foreigners. But after the initial awe, they soon realise there is no romance in the society. India is just the reverse — pathetic first impression. But slowly it grows on them as they begin to see the country with all its complexities. Its strength lay in the maturity of its institutions — parliament, judiciary et al — where you are treated like a free citizen with access to certain rights. If only India was able to fix one thing —  its infrastructure — it will be sheer magic.
China isn’t a democracy and for the common man it is no big deal as long as his needs and growth is taken care of. So far, the Chinese government has done well — there is progress, lives have dramatically improved. But there is a difference. Unlike India where no one person can change the country’s destiny, China has a dictator — albeit a benevolent one. This centrally governed China is its boon and bane. The government plays God here controlling everything. Hence, decisions are quick, policy-execution is well aligned and progress more certain. But at a time when the economic slowdown is taking its toll, the tendency to blame the government is high. Amid growing inequality, there are 23 million people with no jobs. 

Money is the Message
Money is the biggest driver for Chinese workers. Initially, no matter what we did, everybody left office at 5.30. I thought people were disengaged. It took me two years to fix it. I decided to make 50 percent of the salary variable. If you achieved 80 percent of the goals, you got 100 percent of the variable and your take home would be 20 percent more than the industry. Guess what? We had another problem. Nobody wanted to leave.
Unlike Indians, Chinese are great at execution but poor problem solvers. A Chinese professor aptly summed up the difference between India and China for me: Indians can’t work, and Chinese can’t think. But overall this is a nice place for expats. In most big cities, you will find at least one international school. Major hospitals have a foreigner section. China feels safe. Almost 90 percent of the women here work. But economic slowdown has had its impact. You hear of stray cases in Guangzhou where factories have shut down and are relocating to Vietnam.
Export-oriented sectors are reeling. I see an exodus of manufacturing, especially low-end ones, to Vietnam. China may see the bottom 20 percent move out of the country. The average middle class Chinese aren’t yet seriously affected. Expats may have lost their jobs but (I) haven’t yet heard of pay cuts and job losses among Chinese workers. Right now, China is in a wait-and-watch mode. At a macro level, I see a significant shift. Earlier, exporters from China were gung-ho and those marketing into China were relatively less so. Today, tables have turned as exporters are hurting badly while those selling into China are upbeat. MNC CEOs here are under pressure from their headquarters to grow business as the US and Europe bottoms out. But cost cuts is high on priority. For many, this crisis could be one of their biggest opportunities.

(This story appears in the 05 June, 2009 issue of Forbes India. You can buy our tablet version from To visit our Archives, click here.)

Show More
Post Your Comment
Required, will not be published
All comments are moderated
  • Roger

    Another bogus article perpetuating stereotypes about chinese creativity. Give it a rest...

    on Jan 17, 2011
  • Josh

    I agree with this. Chinese are too busy thinking about money to think about something else. Their job is not really creative.

    on Jun 16, 2010
  • Linus Fernandes

    I do not like generalizations. China's progress since 1978 belies the statement that Chinese can't think. So no, I disagree. As for Indians , we work harder and better abroad when we see tangible rewards for our efforts and merit and excellence is rewarded. In India, we tend to be satisfied with the beginning of excellence and are discouraged from pursuing nirvana in excellence, both at the personal and group level.

    on Jul 4, 2009
  • Rupesh

    i do not agree with the statement as chinese can think but they are controlled , similarly many indians are running succesfull business with chinese teams in china so other way is also true that indians can really work hard

    on Jun 3, 2009
  • Riya

    I partly agree to the statement, & quot;Indians cant work and Chinese cant think & quot;. I partly agree because i am sure Chinese cant think, they are very good imitators. But Indians can work hard as well as think! for those who feel Indians cannot work hard, is not taking into consideration the representative sample.

    on May 22, 2009
  • Sudhir

    I had been to China, and I agree with this, to some extent...

    on May 22, 2009
  • Investwiz

    Simple and short message..i like it!

    on May 22, 2009
  • Sanjeev Jain

    Good one and real on that.

    on May 22, 2009
  • Preeti

    Only for some reasons i m agree with this!

    on May 21, 2009
The Audacity of Hope
Saving Suzlon