https://api.forbesindia.com/nodeapi/v1/frb/search-summary

search

The strength of the party's progressive wing was on vivid display in South Florida, starting in the first minutes of the debate when Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts branded the federal government as thoroughly corrupt

US Democrats diverge on economy and immigration in first debate

Candidates take the stage for the first Democratic presidential debate in Miami on Wednesday night, June 26, 2019. From left: Mayor Bill de Blasio of New York Rep. Tim Ryan of Ohio Julián Castro, the former housing secretary Sen. Cory Booker of New Jersey Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts former Representative Beto O’Rourke of Texas Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota Rep. Tulsi Gabbard of Hawaii Gov. Jay Inslee of Washington and former Representative John Delaney of Maryland. Image: Doug Mills/The New York TimesMIAMI — Democratic presidential candidates leveled a stark critique  of President Donald Trump’s immigration policies and the condition of  the American working class in the first primary debate Wednesday but  split in unmistakable terms over just how aggressively the next  president should seek to transform the country along more liberal lines.The strength of the party’s progressive wing was on vivid display in  South Florida, starting in the first minutes of the debate when Sen.  Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts branded the federal government as  thoroughly corrupt. Warren, the highest-polling candidate onstage,  called for the government to bring to heel oil companies and  pharmaceutical companies, and embraced the replacement of private health  insurance with single-payer care.“We need to make structural change in our government, in our economy  and in our country,” Warren said, setting the tone for the handful of  populists in the debate.Joining Warren in driving hard from the left were two lesser-known  candidates — Julián Castro, the former housing secretary, and Mayor Bill  de Blasio of New York — who sought to jump-start their campaigns by  confronting rivals who hesitated to match their progressive demands on  immigration, health care and national security policy.The debate, the first of two featuring 10 candidates each,  underscored just how sharply Democrats have veered in a liberal  direction since Trump’s election. On issues ranging from immigration and  health care to gun control and foreign policy, they demonstrated that  they were far more uneasy about being perceived as insufficiently  progressive by primary voters than about inviting Republican attacks in  the general election.But there were also several avowed pragmatists who voiced hesitation  or outright disagreement over some of their party’s most ambitious  policy demands. Most prominent among them was Sen. Amy Klobuchar of  Minnesota, who expressed doubts about liberal plans for single-payer  health care and free college education she instead called for more  modest alternatives like the creation of an optional government-backed  health insurance plan.“It’s a bold approach it’s something that Barack Obama wanted to  do,” Klobuchar said, linking her more moderate views to those of one of  the most popular Democrats in the country. She added, of a single-payer  bill written by Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont: “I am just simply  concerned about kicking half of America off of their health insurance in  four years.”Although Warren and Klobuchar did not engage the other by name,  Warren drew loud applause by retorting that politicians who suggest  “Medicare for all” is impractical are really telling Americans “they  just won’t fight for it.”Other candidates tried to chart a middle path between those poles on  health care, with Sen. Cory Booker of New Jersey saying that he  supported single-payer care but would embrace more incremental options  as well. “We have to do the things, immediately, that are going to  provide better care,” he said.At times the forum became a free-for-all of cross talk among  candidates desperate to wedge their personalities and signature ideas  into brief snippets of television airtime. But even the disagreements  were squarely over matters of policy substance: There were no personal  attacks or criticisms of character, and nothing resembling the  Trump-style personal taunts that came to define the last crowded  presidential primary, waged among Republicans in 2016.There were Democrats boasting about their executive résumés — Gov.  Jay Inslee of Washington trumpeted the laws he had personally enacted,  on matters like health care and abortion rights — and those who focused  on sharing aspects of their personal biographies Klobuchar, for  instance, spoke of her father, who attended community college.Perhaps mindful of the debate’s South Florida venue, several took  pains to flaunt their Spanish-language skills, particularly when it came  time to discuss immigration. Among those were Booker, Castro and former  Rep. Beto O’Rourke of Texas.“The situation now is unacceptable,” Booker said in Spanish, of the  crisis unfolding on the Mexican border. “This president has attacked, he  has demonized immigrants. I am going to change this.”After drawing little notice initially, Booker offered a series of  commanding answers in the second hour of the two-hour debate on issues  such as guns and LGBT rights, and he repeatedly highlighted his  residency in heavily black Newark, New Jersey.Booker is one of two African Americans in the debate field, along  with Sena. Kamala Harris of California, who will appear Thursday. Former  Vice President Joe Biden enjoys an early lead in the polls thanks in  part to his support among black voters.Castro, the former mayor of San Antonio, dominated the segment  devoted to immigration, promoting his proposal to decriminalize illegal  immigration — a policy that Warren has adopted in recent days and that  Republicans have gleefully highlighted to argue that Democrats support  open borders.Turning to O’Rourke, whose unsuccessful 2018 Senate bid and  presidential candidacy have overshadowed him, Castro asked his fellow  Texan why he would not support making illegal immigration a civil  offense. “I just think it’s a mistake, Beto,” said Castro.O’Rourke noted that he had introduced legislation in Congress to  decriminalize “those seeking asylum” and said that he had unveiled a  comprehensive immigration overhaul.But Castro interjected that it was not sufficient to only relieve  those seeking asylum from criminal penalty because many of those charged  for crossing the border illegally are “undocumented immigrants.”Booker made clear that he sided with Castro on the question, an  illustration of the party’s shifting center of gravity on perhaps the  dominant issue of the Trump era.While the candidates looking to break out were most eager to confront  others onstage, the better-known and better-financed contenders were  less eager to duel with one another.When the debate turned to tech companies, Booker stopped short of  endorsing Warren’s call to break up the biggest firms, like Facebook and  Google, while saying it was clear that the economy “is not working for  average Americans.”When Booker was reminded that he had attacked Warren this year for  naming some of the corporations she would break up, he retreated. “I  don’t think we disagree,” he said, adding that he also felt strongly  about “the need to check corporate consolidation.”O’Rourke also declined to hit back when he found himself under attack, first by de Blasio and then by Castro.When the moderators asked the 10 candidates which of them would  support eliminating private health insurance as part of a single-payer  health care plan, only Warren and de Blasio raised their hands.“How can you defend a system that’s not working?” de Blasio demanded of O’Rourke.Klobuchar was the most firm in staking her claim to moderate terrain  and also got off a handful of one-liners that drew applause and laughs.When Inslee boasted about his record in support of abortion rights, Klobuchar noted the gender diversity of the candidates.“I want to say there’s three women up here who have fought pretty hard for a woman’s right to choose,” she said.And she scorched Trump for his erratic Twitter posts. “I don’t think  we should conduct foreign policy in our bathrobe at 5 in the morning,”  she said.There was little discussion of foreign policy until near the end of  the debate when two little-known House lawmakers, Tulsi Gabbard of  Hawaii and Tim Ryan of Ohio, clashed over how aggressively to target the  Taliban.Ryan also used his limited time to challenge his own party.“We are  not connecting to the working-class people in the very states that I  represent in the industrial Midwest,” he said, scorning Democrats’ “Ivy  League” attitude.De Blasio was the most aggressive candidate when it came to  confronting his rivals. But it was unclear if the New York mayor, who  polls indicate is disliked by those Democrats who have heard him, would  reap the benefit from his carrying the liberal banner.Warren’s repeated denunciations of  economic elites and Washington’s governing class won repeated ovations.  But her unabashed willingness to terminate private health care, a  question she had evaded in the past, alarmed some members of her own  party who fear that embracing a single-payer system would hand  Republicans a political weapon in a country where nearly 60% of people  are on private plans.Warren was less precise when she asked how she would push through her  agenda if Republicans still control the Senate in 2021. And while she  never mentioned her rivals by name, it was clear Warren is building a  case for why Democrats should reject Biden’s consensus-oriented  politics.For the most part, though, the contenders trumpeted their own  proposals and résumés while training their fire on Trump and Republican  economic policies, which they said were favoring the wealthy.“He says wind turbines cause cancer. We know they cause jobs,” Inslee said.The debate came at a moment when party  activists were unified on the urgency of ejecting Trump from the White  House but deeply divided over the best approach.Dating to the day after Trump’s inauguration, when millions of women  marched in U.S. cities, Democratic contempt for the president has  produced a supercharged liberal activism — and prompted a new level of  engagement culminating in last year’s elections, which saw the largest  turnout for a midterm campaign in a half-century.This energy has carried over into 2019, as many of the Democratic  hopefuls have attracted unusually large crowds at early rallies and  forums, large numbers of small-dollar donors and hundreds of volunteers  who are already following every dip and rise in the race.And for many of the party’s primary voters, the back-to-back debates  represented their first extended look at the Democrats’ historically  large, and diverse, field.So far, the race has been chiefly defined by a central question:  Should Democrats rally behind Biden, a moderate who is the field’s  best-known candidate, or find a more progressive alternative? While  Biden has proved to be resilient in the polls since entering the race in  April, he is a fragile front-runner and has already seen his advantage  ebb in Iowa and New Hampshire.Sanders has retained much of the grassroots and financial network  that powered him to unexpected success in the 2016 Democratic race, but  he has struggled to expand his appeal beyond his committed supporters.That is in part because the party’s left flank now has a wealth of  alternatives, including Warren, who has recently surged in a number of  surveys after months of laying out a series of ambitious policy  proposals.

US Democrats diverge on economy and immigration in first debate

The strength of the party's progressive wing was on vivid display in South Florida, starting in the first minutes of the debate when Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts branded the federal governme

Latest News

On Everyone’s Radar

US Democrats diverge on economy and immigration in first debate

The strength of the party's progressive wing was on vivid display in South Florida, starting in the first minutes of the debate when Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts branded the federal governme... Read More

Latest News

On Everyone’s Radar

The strength of the party's progressive wing was on vivid display in South Florida, starting in the first minutes of the debate when Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts branded the federal governme