My Mentor: My father. He was the son of a daroga. He studied in a village and qualified to be an M.A. L.L.B and D.Phil from the Allahabad university. During World War II, he enrolled in the Army and, after cessation of hostilities, was sent to the College of Military Engineering to become an engineer. He was later commissioned in the Corps of Engineer as an officer.
How he has helped me hone my leadership skills: He imbibed in me the capacity to be a good recipient of ideas and an excellent salesman of my own innovative thinking. To be a team leader was important but it was equally important for me to be a good team player.
His advice that has stayed with me: The attainment of perfection was of paramount concern in all activities of ones personality. He was an epitome of integrity. He wanted me to be forthright in my views and above board in my dealings.
Vinod Rai has a good first serve. He takes full advantage of his over six-foot frame to smash the ball across the court. The opponent, a colleague of his, has to receive the ball at an uncomfortable height. It is not competitive tennis; it is a match that is almost like evening banter. But the players are at it with enthusiasm. The venue is an abandoned parking lot converted into a tennis court at the old office of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) in Delhi, a few hundred metres away from the spanking new Dholpur stone structure that is the new CAG office complex.
Rai has just inaugurated the court and is playing the first match with his colleagues. “After we got a new office, we decided to convert this space into a tennis court,” says 62-year-old Rai, who has been playing tennis and climbing mountains since he was in college. But it is not the aces he serves on the tennis court that have made him famous.
As Comptroller and Auditor General of India, Rai has served up a few uncomfortable audit reports that have pinned many government departments beyond the baseline.
He has consistently hit the headlines for his unforgiving audits, ranging from the scathing report on the shoddy preparation for the Commonwealth Games to the latest on spectrum allocations for second generation (2G) telecom services.
Bureaucratic grapevine suggests there was quite a bit of pressure on Rai to dilute the 2G report but he held fast, merely asking his people to check for unnecessarily harsh or unfair language.
The report ripped apart the government, even pointing a finger at the prime minister for arbitrarily giving away spectrum, a valuable and limited national resource. The CAG report said the ultimate loss to the exchequer could be as high as Rs 1.76 lakh crore.
The report, coupled with the leak of a set of recorded conversations with a corporate lobbyist, has already cost Andimuthu Raja his job as telecom minister and stalled the Winter Session of Parliament.
Rai is among that rare breed of civil servants who know how to get work done in the government. A former colleague says Rai has an uncanny ability to cut through red tape.
One morning in January 2006, top officials of the finance ministry were summoned by then finance minister P. Chidambaram. The minister was reviewing proposals for the forthcoming Budget and there was a paragraph in his speech about the setting up of India Infrastructure Finance Company, something he had announced in the previous Budget speech as well. The hitch was the company had not yet been incorporated.
“Chidambaram was livid. He asked how long will you guys take to just incorporate a company,” remembers a bureaucrat familiar with the incident. The usual passing-the-buck had happened within the ministry and both the department of economic affairs and the department of financial services had not been able to get the company going.
As Chidambaram flew into a rage, Rai, who was then heading the department of economic affairs, butted in and said it would be done by the weekend. After he came back to his office, Rai called a joint secretary in the ministry of corporate affairs and told him this company had to be registered by that evening. The official told him it was next to impossible and offered to brief him on the long process and the required documentation.
“I am told by your colleagues that you are a very good officer. It is the prestige of the department at stake. This has to be done,” he told him. The official reportedly said that since Rai had challenged his competency, he had to get it done.
The entire machinery cranked into action, with the registrar of companies even getting a diesel generator from another department to print the incorporation certificate because there was a power cut.
(This story appears in the 31 December, 2010 issue of Forbes India. To visit our Archives, click here.)