Forbes India 15th Anniversary Special

How Cree Perfected The 20-Year Lightbulb

How a North Carolina LED maker built a better mousetrap—and doubled its market cap to $7 billion in just one year

Published: Jun 22, 2013 06:01:28 AM IST
Updated: Jun 18, 2013 12:04:43 PM IST
How Cree Perfected The 20-Year Lightbulb
Image: Michael J. N. Bowles for Forbes
Cree’s CEO Chuck Swoboda wants to change the way America is lit. Investors are basking in the glow

In the ad for Cree lightbulbs, snow whips across a desolate field as a bagpipe creaks out ‘Amazing Grace’. An announcer holds up a lightbulb and speaks into the camera. “Mr Edison, today we lay to rest your creation, the incandescent lightbulb. I know you’re not shocked, sir. You knew that it needed an unreasonable amount of energy to do its job and that it had the life span of a lucky bug.”

He fits the bulb into a tiny wooden casket and places it into a hole in the ground. Then we see Cree’s new LED bulb. “The biggest thing since the lightbulb,” we’re told.

It’s a fun commercial, and Chuck Swoboda, CEO of Cree, means no disrespect. “We made sure the Edison estate was okay with it,” he says. “There’s an Edison quote that has always been inspirational to us: ‘There’s a better way to do it. Find it.’”

Swoboda believes his company has done just that. More than 130 years after Thomas Edison created the first saleable lightbulb, his design remains little changed. Electricity flows across a resistant wire in an oxygen-free environment and glows. Cree’s lightbulb uses an array of light-emitting diodes to create a similar rich, warm light without the flicker of compact fluorescent bulbs.

It does so with unassailable economy. An incandescent bulb costs $1 and uses $7 of electricity a year if used three hours a day. A Cree bulb may cost $10, but uses 10 percent of the electricity, costing $1 a year. And while an old-school bulb will burn out in less than two years, LED bulbs will work for more than 20 years. At $9.97 for the equivalent of a 40-watt incandescent, or $12.97 for a 60-watt replacement, the Cree bulbs are cheaper than offerings from rivals.

That performance is a big reason Cree boasts $1.3 billion in sales and $70 million in earnings. Its market cap of $7 billion has doubled in less than a year; investors foresee broad adoption of LEDs once federal lighting standards force the phase-out of 40- and 60-watt incandescents in 2014. Of roughly 6 billion lightbulbs in American homes, 3.6 billion are incandescents. Lighting sucks up 14 percent of America’s electricity; replacing all those Edison bulbs with LEDs could cut that demand in half.

The Durham, North Carolina, company was founded in 1987 and went public in 1993. In those early years, it had a good business selling semiconductor chips made of gallium nitride that glow when an electric current is passed through them. But the early light-emitting diodes came in only two colours: Red and green.

The industry’s elusive Holy Grail was a ‘white’ LED. If they could somehow create a bright blue LED, they could combine it with the red and green to make what the human eye would perceive as white light. In 1994 a researcher at Japanese company Nichia proved it could be done.

Cree’s engineers followed soon after with their own bright blue LED chip made from wafers of silicon carbide. “Everything came from this,” says Swoboda, who joined the company in 1993, when it had only 30 workers. It now boasts over 6,000.

At first, Cree just made the chips and sold them to the LED makers; early uses included backlit car dashboards and cellphones. The potential seemed so great that in 2004 analysts were calling Cree the next Intel. But white LED lights weren’t ready for the residential market. Early fixtures cost too much and suffered from another then-unsolved problem: LEDs are a directional light source; they cast light in only one direction. That’s fine if you want to spotlight something but a non-starter if your aim is to replace the all-around glow of incandescents.

Playing to their strengths, LED makers started marketing so-called downlights. Cree in 2007 bought Chinese light-fixture maker Cotco and in 2008 acquired LED Lighting Fixtures. It began a relationship with Home Depot selling down- lights under its EcoSmart brand.

It hadn’t even tried developing an incandescent replacement, instead focusing on municipalities and industrial customers. Anchorage, Alaska, replaced 16,000 high-pressure sodium streetlights with LEDs; Los Angeles is swapping out 140,000. Walmart installed LEDs at hundreds of stores. To profit from this industrial market, Cree in 2011 bought fixture manufacturer Ruud for $525 million.

So how to make LEDs mimic incan- descents? The key was in redesigning the filament tower in the middle of the bulb, with 10 or 20 LEDs of varying colours. Cree’s configuration let the individual light sources overlap, creating an omnidirectional glow.

For now, Home Depot is the only place you can buy the Cree, part of an exclusive deal to roll out the bulb in more than 2,000 stores. “The exclusivity is to be negotiated. We will look at other partnerships at some point,” says Swoboda.

Home Depot expects to get some mileage: “We’ve worked together with Cree over nearly two years to develop what is the most affordable, highest- quality LED bulb on the market,” says Mark Voykovic, who oversees the partnership for the retailer.

But bulbs are just the start. Because they seldom need to be replaced, LED lights can be built into fixtures and furniture. Professor Michael Siminovitch, head of the California Lighting Technology Center at University of California, Davis, envisions a world of LEDs programmed to change colour and intensity throughout the day, matching light from the sun. He thinks smart LED lighting will improve moods and reduce seasonal depression. Cree and its rivals are making “really, really good first steps” toward this future, he says.

It’s all this unmet potential that leaves Swoboda far from satisfied. “I don’t think we’ve accomplished that much,” he says. “The world is still lit with incandescent bulbs.” Burying Edison will take a while.

(This story appears in the 28 June, 2013 issue of Forbes India. To visit our Archives, click here.)

Post Your Comment
Required, will not be published
All comments are moderated
  • Mehsum Abbas

    this is something I heard off some time back. but today its a reality. For every inventor, there are few masterminds who take the invention to new heights. here it is for the light-bulbs.

    on Jun 23, 2013
  • M.l.panicker

    That means light years are nearer.

    on Jun 22, 2013