Down round for Paytm

With increasing losses, Paytm's investors may be unwilling to put money at a $13-15 billion valuation

By Samar Srivastava, Forbes India Staff

Published: Oct 22, 2019 03:59:41 PM IST

Updated: Oct 23, 2019 11:23:13 AM IST

Full Bio

Image: Shutterstock

When Paytm raised money from Berkshire Hathaway in August 2018, it marked a significant fundraising coup for the company. Although Warren Buffett, CEO of Berkshire Hathaway, wasn’t involved in the transaction, Paytm, then eight years old, had received the imprimatur of the world’s most successful investment firm. Todd Combs, Buffett’s lieutenant, who led the deal, would be on Paytm's board.

But missing from most headlines was the fact that at a $10 billion valuation for Paytm, Berkshire had invested at a significant discount to the then-prevailing $13-15 billion valuation. Paytm shares in the unlisted market valued it at ₹20,200 per share or about 110,650 crore ($15.8 billion) in October 2018.

As Paytm prepares for a fresh round of fundraising, it’s likely that this could be a ‘down round’—where the valuation is lower than previous ones. Paytm is in talks with T Rowe Price and existing investors Alibaba and SoftBank. Its shares available with brokers who deal in unlisted securities have lost about 20 percent in the last year to quote at ₹16,000 a share, according to three brokers, implying a 20 percent cut in its valuation. The market for unlisted securities can be illiquid and there is no data on the number of shares that have changed hands at this price. A Paytm spokesperson declined to comment on the fundraising.

“Its momentum is not what it has been,” says Jayath Kolla, founder and partner at Convergence Catalyst, a consultancy. After the initial increase in transactions post demonetisation, the company has seen its dominance challenged by Flipkart’s PhonePe and Google Pay. “If Google Pay launches after you and gets traction, then what is your competitive moat?” asks Kolla. Other divisions like Paytm Mall and Paytm Payments Bank have also failed to turn a profit. The company lost ₹4,217 crore in the year ended March 2019, up from the ₹1,604 crore it lost the previous year.

In 2016 and early 2017, Flipkart investors Morgan Stanley, Fidelity and Valic marked down the company’s valuation to under $10 billion. In May 2018, Walmart acquired the company for $22 billion. It remains to be seen if the Paytm story has a similar ending.

(This story appears in the 08 November, 2019 issue of Forbes India. To visit our Archives, click here.)