The heart of the matter are WhatsApp’s entire default service and Facebook’s specific “Secret Conversations” feature on Messenger that allows users to opt-in for end-to-end encrypted messaging; Image: Shutterstock
“ “A mechanism that permits the identification of the end-to-end encrypted communications of all users—the vast majority of whom are law-abiding citizens—does not satisfy the ‘least restrictive’ means requirement.”—Facebook petition
“ “Companies would be collecting more information about their users at a time when people want companies to have less information about them.”—WhatsApp Blog
“ “[T]he Government cannot invade law abiding citizens’ fundamental rights merely in the hope of investigating more potential criminals.”—Facebook petition
“ “Compelling an intermediary to fundamentally alter its platform to enable the ability to identify the first originator of information in India falls far outside ‘due diligence’.”—WhatsApp petition