Prime Minister Narendra Modi launched three gold-related schemes on Thursday in a bid to rein in the country’s appetite for the yellow metal. The three schemes—namely, the Gold Monetisation Scheme (GMS), Gold Sovereign Bond Scheme and the Gold Coin and Bullion Scheme—will help curtail gold imports and utilise at least 20,000 tonnes of the precious metal owned by Indian households.
Modi said the idea is to urge Indian women, the primary drivers of gold consumption, to invest in these schemes. “Women usually do not own anything... a house or a car is usually owned by their husbands or sons, but gold is a matter of their strength,” he said, while also launching the country’s first national gold coin engraved with the Ashok Chakra. The Ministry of Finance has added that the gold would be secure. “Gold is already the savings vehicle of choice for many households and it is essential to tap the institutional market by giving savers an option to hold these savings within the formal financial system, transparently,” said Somasundaram PR, managing director, India, World Gold Council. “This will bring a range of collateral benefits to the industry by significantly raising infrastructure standards and ensuring trust in the industry and in gold.”
The government’s goal is to reduce the country’s burgeoning current account deficit (CAD), which is the difference between total exports and imports. India’s CAD widened to $6.2 billion in the April-June quarter as exports remained lack-lustre and foreign investments dropped. With gold imports inflating the CAD, last year the government was prompted to restrict imports; the restrictions have hence been lifted. India is the world’s highest consumer of gold, buying 562 tonnes compared to China’s 548 tonnes.
But will these gold schemes work? “These schemes could help on the margin but they do not address the underlying problem, which is households’ need for alternative assets for their portfolio diversification,” said Jahangir Aziz, chief Asia economist, JPMorgan. Experts believe the psychological and sociological compulsions that make Indians hoard gold can be broken if the price is right. But along with gold schemes, the need of the hour is to expand the secondary market in corporate bonds, have inflation-linked bonds in much bigger size and improve the price of state government bonds. “We will get used to trading various state government bonds if the market is developed enough for households to have confidence,” said Aziz.
And there are no quick results. “These schemes will be transformative for the Indian gold industry. However, expectations from the schemes in the short term must be tempered, as it will take time to build the infrastructure and products and for customer acceptance to grow,” said Somasundaram. A word of caution from analysts for the short term: If the US Federal Reserve hikes interest rates, then global commodity prices will drop, leading to a fall in gold prices as well.
Will consumers still invest?
Check out our Festive offers upto Rs.1000/- off website prices on subscriptions + Gift card worth Rs 500/- from Eatbetterco.com. Click here to know more.
Government of India is considering setting up of an apex body for gold management. This is a welcome initiative. Long overdue. At least at this stage, Govt must not miss the chance to put in place an apex body responsible for gold management, coordinating the roles of various agencies and stakeholders interested in dealing in the yellow metal. Mapping domestic stock of gold, ensuring adequate supply of gold in the Indian market for various uses from pharmaceutical to jewellery manufacture and export, financing procurement, processing and marketing gold and gold-based products and purity of gold products sold in domestic markets and export could get covered under the ambit of the board.In this context, please see my online comments on this article posted on November 5, 2015.on Feb 22, 2016
I am positive about the success of the schemes in the long run. Or, rather, there is no option to fail, if gold management in india has to happen. GOI and RBI have to now seriously ponder over putting in place institutional arrangement for gold management. From mapping of surface gold stock, to standardising gold stock with government/RBI and institutions, to managing export and import, to preventing leakages and smuggling, taskes are multi-dimensional. May I quote from my own article "Gold management needs a makeover" published in the Hindu Business Line on April 13, 2015 a relevant paragraph?: "INSTITUTIONAL CHANGE The time is ripe for authorities to think in terms of dedicated professional institutions at the regional/state level, which will handle gold from a banking angle. An apex body should be equipped with linkages for import and export of gold and gold products with borrowing and lending capabilities. States like Kerala have successfully intervened in other similar sectors like chits/kuris and lotteries, which were also areas of exploitation by vested interests. Private players had to fall in line and function with discipline and self-regulation. Establishment of 'Gold Corporations' with state participation could also be debated. Such an institution can act as a depository where the gold possession of individuals now in bank lockers and the pledged gold can find a safe shelter, provided the purity can be ensured, and the 'Corporation' can find the resources and skill to deal in gold and retain the customers' confidence." M G Warrier, Mumbaion Nov 5, 2015