ASK Private Wealth Hurun India index comes up with a comprehensive list of valuations, numbers and types of ‘animals’, what is strikingly missing in the startup forest is animal instinct in terms of focusing on unit economics and building a sustainable business
Illustration: Chaitanya Dinesh Surpur
November 2021. With an issue size of Rs 18,300 crore, it was billed as one of the largest IPOs in India. And on day 1, it turned out to be one of the worst stock market debuts, as the stock dipped over 27 percent. At Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), the shares listed at Rs 1,950, a discount of 9.3 percent over the issue price. That’s the story of One97 Communications, which entered the IPO market with a valuation of close to $19 billion at the top end of its price band. Over one-and-a-half years later, the stock was trading at Rs 851 on June 27 this year, and the company posted a loss of Rs 1,855.8 crore in FY23. Clearly, there was a gross mismatch in private valuation and public market reality.
A few months earlier, in July 2021, there was another blockbuster listing. Zomato closed day 1 of its listing at Rs 125.85, which was 65.6 percent over the IPO price. Almost two years later, the stock is trading at Rs 76.65 on June 27, and the food delivery startup closed FY23 with a loss of Rs 971 crore. Again, there was a wide contradiction in private valuation and public market reality.
Fast forward to June 2023. It’s funding winter in India; deeply funded, and not-so-deeply funded startups are competing in terms of who can cut expenses the most—mass layoffs being the lowest hanging fruit—to extend their runway, and the startup ecosystem is still buzzing with talks of unicorns, cheetahs and gazelles. Let’s have a look at some of the numbers churned out by ASK Private Wealth Hurun India Future Unicorn Index 2023. “India's future unicorns are worth $57 billion,” underlines the annual report, which introduces two new species of animals in the startup jungle. While ‘cheetahs’ are valued between $200 million and $500 million, and are most likely to enter the unicorn stable in five years, ‘gazelles’ are valued between $500 million and $1 billion, and are tipped to cross $1 billion in valuation within three years.
A closer look at the performance of most of the cheetahs and gazelles again underlines one stark reality: There is a gross mismatch in valuation and performance. Most of the ‘animals’ are overfed in terms of funding, and are in heavy losses. Let’s start with quick commerce platform Zepto. The startup, which has scooped up around $360 million in funding so far and was last valued at close to $835 million, closed FY22 with a loss of Rs 390.4 crore. The revenue, in FY22, stood at Rs 142.4 crore. Then there is Rapido. The bike taxi aggregator has got $310 million in funding, closed FY22 with a loss of Rs 439 crore, and a revenue of Rs 144.8 crore. Another gazelle tipped to become a unicorn is Leap. The India entity of the fintech platform for students had an operating revenue of just Rs 6.35 crore in FY21, and a loss of Rs 3.84 crore. The startup is yet to file financials for FY22.
The story is more or less the same when it comes to cheetahs. The index goes on to describe cheetahs, which are the fastest mammals on land over short distances and have exceptional stride length. “They are nimble at high speeds, and the length between their steps is six to seven metres and four strides are completed per second,” is how the description reads. Now, when we compare the performance of Dunzo the cheetah, one gets to see the speed of loss and not the revenue. Look at FY22 numbers: Loss was Rs 464 crore, and revenue was Rs 54.3 crore.Also see: From top angel investors to best educational institutes, a look at players in the Indian startup landscape
It’s high time, reckon industry observers, players and commentators, that the startup ecosystem starts looking beyond valuations. The fascination with valuations in India and globally has created an atmosphere where inflated numbers rather than the robustness of the business model, sustainable unit economics, and profitability have become the primary success metric, points out Anirudh A Damani, managing partner at Artha Venture Fund. Startup founders often get caught up in high paper valuations derived from the promises of exceptional future performance. Rather than cautioning founders, the startup ecosystem stakeholders often celebrate these high valuations as a mark of success, thereby creating unrealistic expectations and pressures. “This leads to deleterious circumstances for the founders and their ventures when the promised goals are inevitably missed,” says Damani. While crucial for gauging investor sentiment and serving as a milestone in a startup's journey, valuations aren't an end in themselves. “Our ecosystem must celebrate real, tangible metrics like revenues, margins, return on capital employed, profits, and growth,” he adds.
Agrees Ashish Kapur, CEO of Invest Shoppe India, a wealth management and advisory company. Commenting on loss-making startups and their stock market debuts, he points out that prices of most of these stocks have nosedived. “Even today most of these shares are trading at a deep discount to their peak valuations,” he says. While the business models of most of them are certainly robust, valuations had to ultimately fall in line with the established principles sooner or later. Sadly, as always, it was the unsuspecting average investor who lost heavily when reality ultimately returned to this asset class. “It’s a grim reminder to always stick to the established valuation principles and resist temptation to chase hype and noise,” he says.
Underlining the importance of giving preference to sanity over vanity, Kapur points out the words of wisdom shared by investment guru Benjamin Graham: “The worth of a business is measured not by what has been put into it but by what can be taken out of it”. These words, Kapur reckons, have resonated whenever sanity has returned after an irrational bull run in any asset class. Surprisingly, every exuberant upsurge is supported by weird, new ideas on pricing and valuation contradicting the well-established and time-tested principles on which assets ought to be valued. Spin doctors create an illusion that ‘this time it is different'. “Worldwide more wealth destruction must have happened in trying to chase these new paradigm shifts away from the established norms than any other phenomenon in the financial markets,” he avers.
Back in India, as the ASK Private Wealth Hurun India index comes up with a comprehensive list of valuations, numbers and types of ‘animals’, what is strikingly missing in the startup forest is animal instinct in terms of focusing on unit economics and building a sustainable business.